Skip to the content

How often to shop home insurance on the FAIR Plan

Shop for a new policy at least once a year, starting about 120 days before your FAIR Plan policy renews. Shop again whenever something changes that an insurer would price, like finished wildfire work or a company that starts writing in your area. This calendar shows what to do at each checkpoint and what to keep on file in between.

FAIR Plan desk · Tutorial · By insuremaxxer staff · Updated · 8 min read

A stucco house with a tile roof above dry chaparral
A stucco house with a tile roof above dry chaparral. Photo: Casa.

The short version

  • Shop every year before your FAIR Plan renewal, starting about 120 days out, because the Plan describes itself as a temporary safety net.
  • You can cancel a FAIR Plan policy at any time and get the unused premium back pro rata, so a mid-year offer is still worth taking.
  • The calendar counts back from 2 fixed points: the Plan's 75-day notice before a non-renewal, and wildfire discounts that start with your next policy period.
  • Keep one file all year with your declarations page, renewal invoice, proof of wildfire work and every quote you get.

How often should you shop when you're on the FAIR Plan?

Shop at least once a year, before every renewal. Shop in between as well whenever something changes that an insurer would look at.

The FAIR Plan says as much itself. Its discount sheet calls the Plan "a temporary safety net, here to support policyholders until coverage offered by a traditional carrier becomes available."

The Department of Insurance said the same thing in an August 3, 2026 alert to agents and brokers. "FAIR Plan policyholders should shop the market regularly rather than assume the FAIR Plan remains their only option," the alert said.

You aren't locked in between renewals either. The Plan's dwelling policy says you may cancel "at any time." The premium from the cancellation date to the end of the term is refunded pro rata, which means day for day.

So the renewal date is the deadline for one decision, which is whether to renew or switch first. It isn't the only day you're allowed to move.

Why does the calendar start 120 days before renewal?

We counted back from fixed dates in the Plan's policy and the state's rules. The day counts are our choice. Here's the reason for each one:

  • The renewal date is on your declarations page (the summary page at the front of the policy). Every other checkpoint counts back from it.
  • 75 days before the policy ends is the Plan's own deadline. Its policy says the Plan can choose not to renew only by sending written notice to your mailing address at least 75 days before expiration.
  • The start of the next policy period is when wildfire discounts begin. The Department of Insurance says savings for finished work are "reflected at the start of the next policy period," and you may need proof or an inspection first.

Starting at 120 days gives you about a month to finish and document work before you ask for quotes. That still leaves 60 days of quoting before the last 30 days, which are for paperwork.

The reshop calendar, checkpoint by checkpoint

  1. Renewal day: start this year's file.

    Write the renewal date where you'll see it. Then set reminders for 120, 90, 75 and 30 days before the next one. If you carry a wrap policy, add its renewal date too. A wrap (also called a difference in conditions, or DIC, policy) adds coverage such as water damage, theft and liability. The FAIR Plan doesn't sell DIC policies, so yours comes from a separate insurer.

    Save the new declarations page and the renewal invoice. Starting January 1, 2027, a 2026 law (AB 69) requires the Plan to send a notice at least once a year that says "YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO SHOP AROUND." It comes with each renewal, on its own page. Keep that page with the rest.

    If you use autopay, sign up again now. The Plan's autopay guidelines say enrollment "does not automatically continue for renewal policies." Full-pay policies, policies billed to a mortgage lender and premium-financed policies can't use autopay. Our guide to FAIR Plan autopay walks through the sign-up.

  2. All year: log your work and watch the market.

    When you finish wildfire safety work, tell your broker that week and keep the receipts and photos. The Plan offers up to 12 wildfire hardening discounts on the wildfire part of a dwelling premium. They apply to policies effective on or after November 15, 2025.

    The list follows the state's Safer from Wildfires actions, such as a Class A fire-rated roof, enclosed eaves, ember-resistant vents and a cleared 5-foot zone around the house. A home in a Firewise USA site in good standing or a Fire Risk Reduction Community earns a community discount as well.

    Watch who's writing new policies, too. On August 3, 2026, the Department listed 11 insurance groups that had committed to stay and grow in California under its Sustainable Insurance Strategy. Our carrier tracker logs each public notice with its date.

  3. 120 days out: check what you're insuring.

    Find your dwelling limit on the declarations page. That's Coverage A, the amount set aside to rebuild the house. If the Inflation Guard box is checked, the Plan can raise that limit at each renewal to follow construction costs. Use this year's number rather than last year's.

    Every quote you collect should use that same rebuild amount, or the prices won't compare. Write it at the top of the file.

    Finish any wildfire work you can get done in the next month, then send proof to your broker. Work that's on record before the renewal can count toward the next policy period.

  4. 90 days out: ask for quotes.

    This is the main shopping window. The Department's advice is to "contact multiple agents and brokers, compare coverage and prices, and ask specifically about companies writing new policies in their area."

    The Department's Home Insurance Finder lists insurers and licensed agents by ZIP code or city. It has a box that narrows the list to insurers "that may write in higher fire risk areas." The Department adds that a listed company "may not be able to accept new business," so ask before you count on one.

    Ask agents to check standard insurers first, then specialty insurers (surplus lines). Ask each insurer for your home's wildfire risk score too. Under the state's Safer from Wildfires regulation, an insurer has to give it to you when you apply, with an explanation of how to lower it.

    Casa, whose team runs this site, quotes California homes on the FAIR Plan with standard insurers first, then specialty insurers. A licensed agent reviews each request. Whoever you ask, give every agent the same rebuild amount from step 3. Ask too whether each quote would replace the FAIR Plan or pair with it as a wrap policy.

    A quote that comes in months before your renewal is still usable, because the Plan refunds unused premium pro rata. Casa's guide to canceling the FAIR Plan before it renews, from the team that runs this site, sets out the order that avoids a gap.

  5. 75 days out: check the mail.

    By now a FAIR Plan non-renewal notice would already have been sent, because the policy requires at least 75 days' notice. If one came, your quotes from step 4 are no longer optional. Our piece on why the FAIR Plan can non-renew a policy covers that notice.

    If nothing came, renewing with the Plan stays available as your fallback while you keep comparing.

  6. 30 days out: decide and do the paperwork.

    If you're switching, do it in this order:

    1. Start the new policy, with its first day on or before your FAIR Plan renewal date.
    2. If you have a mortgage, send the new declarations page to your loan servicer. Federal rules make a servicer that pays from escrow pay insurance bills on time, so tell it before it pays the FAIR Plan renewal.
    3. Cancel the FAIR Plan in writing and give the date it should end. The unused premium from that date comes back pro rata.

    If you're staying, pick a payment plan. The Plan offers full pay, 3 payments (40%, 30% and 30%) or 11 payments. You choose a plan by paying the first amount shown for it on the renewal invoice. Each installment carries a $4.50 fee. Card payments add a 3.5% vendor fee, while bank transfers (ACH) don't. Our guide to FAIR Plan payment plans explains each one.

  7. Renewal day again: start over.

    Whichever way you went, open next year's file today. If you switched, keep the Plan's cancellation confirmation and the record of your refund with it.

What should you keep on file all year?

A single folder saves you from hunting for papers at the 90-day mark. It can be on paper or on your phone. Here's what goes in it and why.

Document Why you keep it
FAIR Plan declarations page It shows the renewal date, dwelling limit and coverages that every quote should match.
Renewal invoice It shows the Plan's price for the new term and the first payment for each payment plan.
Any notice from the Plan A non-renewal or cancellation notice has a deadline on it.
Wrap policy declarations page The wrap has its own renewal date and coverages to match.
Receipts, photos and inspection reports for wildfire work An insurer may ask for proof before a discount applies.
Proof of community status A Firewise USA site or a Fire Risk Reduction Community earns the Plan's community discount.
Every quote, with its date Next year you can see which insurers quoted, at what rebuild amount and with what coverage.
Your loan servicer's name and your loan number The servicer needs a copy of any new policy.

What should make you shop before the calendar says to?

Anything an insurer would price differently is a reason to ask early. Because the Plan refunds unused premium pro rata, a switch in month 5 doesn't waste the rest of the year's payment.

  • You finished a discount item. The Department says different insurers "may offer different discounts, so it pays to compare."
  • Your neighborhood got a wildfire designation. It could have become a Firewise USA site or a Fire Risk Reduction Community.
  • An insurer said it's writing again in your area. The Department announces these in its alerts. Our carrier tracker lists them with their dates.

It also helps to see how your ZIP code is moving. The Plan publishes its policy counts by ZIP code. Our guide to reading the FAIR Plan's policy counts shows how to compare 2 years.

Questions readers ask

Can I shop while my FAIR Plan policy is still active? Yes. The Plan's dwelling policy lets you cancel at any time in writing. The Plan refunds the unused premium pro rata. Start the new policy first, then cancel, so there's no gap.

Will the FAIR Plan tell me when other insurers are interested? You can't count on it. Insurers in the Plan's clearinghouse can look at some policy information and may make an offer. You can also opt out of that sharing. Starting January 1, 2027, the Plan must also send a yearly notice of your right to shop around. Neither one replaces asking for quotes yourself.

Does canceling the FAIR Plan mid-term cost a fee? The Plan's dwelling policy doesn't list a cancellation fee. It refunds the premium from the cancellation date to the end of the term pro rata.

What if no other insurer will take the house this year? Renew with the Plan by paying the first amount on the renewal invoice for the payment plan you want. Then open next year's file and run the calendar again.

Sources

  1. California FAIR Plan, Wildfire Hardening Discounts (last revised November 2025). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  2. California Department of Insurance, FAIR Plan growth slows below 2% as California's insurance market continues to show signs of recovery (agent and broker alert, August 3, 2026). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  3. California FAIR Plan, Dwelling Property Policy, CFP 00 01 (05/2026). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  4. California Legislature, AB 69, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2026 (bill text via CalMatters Digital Democracy). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  5. California FAIR Plan, Autopay Guidelines and Enrollment (last revised August 24, 2026). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  6. California FAIR Plan, Payment Plan Options. Accessed November 17, 2026.
  7. California Department of Insurance, FAQ: Safer from Wildfires Regulation (September 2026). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  8. California Department of Insurance, Home Insurance Finder. Accessed November 17, 2026.
  9. California FAIR Plan, Difference in Conditions (DIC). Accessed November 17, 2026.
  10. California FAIR Plan, Clearinghouse Disclosures. Accessed November 17, 2026.
  11. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 12 CFR 1024.17, Escrow accounts. Accessed November 17, 2026.